ext_123859 ([identity profile] sam-storyteller.livejournal.com) wrote in [personal profile] sam_storyteller 2007-04-11 12:51 am (UTC)

Hi there! Sorry for the delay in replying, I wanted to mull over your comments for a bit :) And I did want to respond. Hope the essay went well :D

I actually became a Who fan because of Eccleston in Heroes, funnily enough. (Is it me or has he gained weight?)

I tend to skip the Niki/Hana/Ted-parts

I don't like writing them, to be perfectly honest :D If I could have reasonably written Niki out, I totally would have.

While on the subject of Jack, I am not very fond of him.

I was thinking when I introduced him that probably a lot of people wouldn't be. He IS an OC, after all. But while Claire does have a lot of really interesting relationships, none of them are romantic, and I wanted her to have something normal -- as normal as things ever are -- for a teenage girl. A boyfriend, or at any rate a suitor. I'm trying to keep Jack less than central, but I'm hoping what he will do is draw the canon characters further in -- interact with them, et cetera.

*the Ouran High School Host Club reference.

That was a totally cheesy and self-gratifying reference, you're right. I just couldn't resist :D

*Not enough Claire-Claude interaction

I'm really wary of this. It seems too easy for him to fall into a father-figure role, and she has two daddies already. There WILL be more, but I want to keep him on his toes -- I don't want him to immediately like her and want to spend time with her. Claude doesn't like people, on the whole.

*Claude let go of his collar and jerked his shoulder up, resettling the shirt over the scar.
This I liked because I could really "see" the motion,


I'm so glad you said that. I loved the mental image of that motion, so I wanted to convey it precisely.

I like this line, because it indicates that if Claude had stayed he would have become Claire's teacher

Absolutely. I think if Claude had still been in Claire's life, he would have been someone she could go to about this, and as soon as she did, he'd have started a ball in motion not only to teach her but also to conceal her. It'd make a great AU.

I really would like to see Claude as Claire's teacher, but unfortunately I don't think that that will happen as she has pretty much come to term with her powers.

I actually talk about this in one of the upcoming chapters -- Claude expounding on what he could do for Claire, if he did teach her. I don't think he'll be her teacher in the time I have left to post this fic, but it's something I envision for the future.

having Bennet shoot/shoot at him a few times on his own, as it otherwise wouldn't technically count as Bennet shooting him.

That was important to me. I didn't want to "whitewash" Bennet -- he did intend to shoot him.

And that this moment spawned the whole "People suck!" attitude that Claude has.

I think it did contribute to it, but Claude's attitude is too deeply ingrained -- I think he already had a great deal of that when he started with the Company.

*Claire and Mr Bennet meeting up again
*Claude-Mr Bennet interaction (that would totally rock)


Oh yes. It's written already. :D

Thank you for all this feedback, it was wonderful to read. And thanks for the link to the Disney fellowship! I will look into that.

Post a comment in response:

If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
More info about formatting

If you are unable to use this captcha for any reason, please contact us by email at support@dreamwidth.org